The Comparison of Biomechanical Breast Models: Initial Results

We present initial results from evaluating the accuracy with which biomechanical breast models based on finite element methods can predict the displacements of tissue within the breast. We investigate the influence of different tissue elasticity values, Poisson’s ratios, boundary conditions, finite element solvers and mesh resolutions on one data set. MR images were acquired before and after compressing a volunteer’s breast gently. These images were aligned using a 3D non-rigid registration algorithm. The boundary conditions (surface displacements) were derived from the result of the non-rigid registration or by assuming no patient motion at the posterior or medial side. Three linear and two non-linear elastic material models were tested. The accuracy of the BBMs was assessed by the Euclidean distance of twelve corresponding anatomical landmarks. Overall, none of the tested material models was obviously superior to another regarding the set of investigated values. A major average error increase was noted for partially inaccurate boundary conditions at high Poisson’s ratios due to introduced volume change. Maximal errors remained, however, high for low Poisson’s ratio due to the landmarks closeness to the inaccurate boundary conditions. Better results were achieved when no boundary conditions were imposed on the posterior side. The choice of finite element solver or mesh resolution had almost no effect on the performance outcome.

View Now